Case Victories – November 2026

We’re frequently asked how we win remands on the many cases that get referred to us. We have found that almost all ALJ decisions have errors in them. It’s pointing out those errors to OGC and the Court which procures the remand.

We are presently finding that the ALJs are not following the new regulations on supportability and consistency. If your client’s decision did not sufficiently analyze both the supportability and consistency of all the medical opinions, we want to review that case for federal court.

We’re excited to share some of our recent case victories with you. Here you can read details directly from our attorneys.

 

Tuttle v. SSA (2:26-cv-00063-WKS) | District of Vermont

This client retained our services at the hearing level for her claim for Disability Insurance Benefits and SSI under Titles II and XVI of the Social Security Act. Following unfavorable decisions from the ALJ and the Appeals Council, we accepted his case for federal court appeal. The case was briefed in Federal Court in July of 2026, arguing the following:

  1. The ALJ properly declined to find the State agency opinions fully persuasive as to physical restrictions, but nevertheless erred due to the lack of any opinion that supports the RFC which he adopted, ultimately yielding a decision that is not supported by substantial evidence.
  2. The ALJ violated 20 C.F.R. §§ 404.1529, 416.929 and SSR 16-3p, by failing to provide sufficient reasons for rejecting Plaintiff’s subjective allegations.

On October 13, 2026, United States District Judge William K. Sessions, III, found that both of Plaintiff’s arguments had merit. He found the ALJ had no valid basis for developing an RFC without updated information as to Plaintiff’s ability to function after her most recent medical developments. While noting that an “ALJ is not required to further develop the record where there are no obvious gaps and the ALJ possesses a complete medical history,” in this case, he found the medical record was materially incomplete and held that such a situation warrants a remand for further proceedings. District Judge Sessions also found error, because the ALJ “did not explicitly address the relevant factors and give specific reasons for his credibility determination,” but instead just “summarized the medical record.” Judge Sessions granted Plaintiff’s request for relief, and remanded the case for further proceedings.

 

McNeilan v. SSA (1:26-cv-00328) | Southern District of Ohio

This was a 2020 claim for Title II disability insurance benefits. The client’s claim was denied initially and again on reconsideration, after his hearing, and at the Appeals Council levels. OLG helped the client appeal the decision in Federal Court in 2026 with a brief that was written and filed by our federal court team. The Southern District of Ohio reviewed our arguments and agreed that the Administrative Law Judge’s (ALJ) decision was not supported by substantial evidence because the ALJ improperly dismissed the client’s Complex Regional Pain Syndrome, Type 2, as non-severe. So, the Southern District of Ohio voluntarily reversed the decision and remanded it for a new hearing and determination.

 

Perry v. SSA (1:26-cv-00257) | District of Idaho

This was a 2022 claim for Title II disability insurance benefits and Title XVI supplemental security income.  The client’s claim was denied initially and again on reconsideration, after his hearing, and at the Appeals Council levels.  OLG helped the client appeal the decision in Federal Court in 2026 with a brief that was written and filed by our federal court team.  The District of Idaho reviewed our arguments and agreed that the Administrative Law Judge’s (ALJ) decision was not supported by substantial evidence because the ALJ failed to properly evaluate the medical opinion of a consultative examiner and also did not provide clear and convincing reasons for rejecting the claimant’s subjective allegations. So, the District of Idaho voluntarily reversed the decision and remanded it for a new hearing and determination.

 

Pike v. SSA (6:26-cv-06429) | Western District of New York

This case was remanded on stip.  There are two MSOs (2024, 2025) from his treating providers that would result in Plaintiff meeting a listing.

The ALJ cherry picked evidence in his s&c explanations for both opinions.  For both opinions, the providers gave supporting/explanatory statements in their opinions that the ALJ ignored.  The ALJ did not even give a clear supportability analysis of the 2025 opinion.  He cited 2 records in his consistency analysis of the 2024 opinion, and 3 records in his consistency analysis of the 2025 opinion.  He omitted positive findings from the same examinations that he cited.

 

To view a full list of Federal Court wins from the month, click here

 

 

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *